A summary of the development ot Mariology, the theology concerning Christ`s mother, Mary.
Don't you know that we will judge angels--how much more matters of this life? I Cor 6:3
Evangelicals and Protestants have numerous disgreements with Roman Catholics and Eastern Orthodox about Mary's role in the life of the Church. Evangelicals and Protestants rely mostly on Scripture for their picture of Mary's role; Roman Catholics and Eastern Orthodox rely mostly on Church tradition for their picture.
How important are these differences concerning Mary? Do they make us theological sparring partners, or do they make us enemies warring against each other for the true faith? Before we can make that determination, we first have to deal with two Protestant prejudices against Roman Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy concerning Mary.
The first of these prejudices is a popular belief among some conservative Evangelicals that Catholics (and Orthodox) are worshipping pagan female deities (Isis, Ishtar, Aprodite/Diana) under the name of Mary. This clain first appeared in Alexander Hislop's 18__ The Two Babylons. Since the book's publication, many conservative Christians--Jack Chick in the late 20th century and numerous contemporary YouTubers today--have read this book, or summaries of this book, and widely promoted its teaching. One such promoter was evangelical minister Ralph Woodrow. In 19__, Woodrow published a reworking of Hislop's book which Woodrow titled Mystery Babylon. When chanllenged by a high school history teacher on Hislop's reliability, Woodrow re-examined The Two Babylons with a skeptical, scholarly eye. Woodrow ended up totally recanting his own book Mystery Babylon and wrote a book titled The Babylon Connection completely debunking Hislop's The Two Babylons. I have read The Babylon Connection and The Two Babylons [still reading] and I side with Woodrow's analysis. Hislop's work is a conspiratorial product of what I call Roman Catholic Derangement Syndrome. There is not a singular reputable secular scholar--one with no dog in the fight--who substantiates Hislop's wild claims.
The second of these prejudices is that Catholics and Orthodox worship Mary. While you may find professing Catholics and Orthodox who cross the line into worship of Mary, both Catholics and Orthodix reject such worship as heresy. Veneration for Mary should be of the same character as respect for parents or the rulers God has placed over us; worship is reserved for the Father, Son, and Holy Spiriit alone.
Yes! | No! |
John MacArthur, a popular Evangelical radio personality, and others accuse us of that. ... And so we come to address this same age-old goddess heresy of paganism in its newest form with the modern goddess having stolen the name of Mary, a terrible dishonor to her. (John MacArthur, Exposing the Idolatry of Mary Worship: Catholic Dogma, Pt. 1) | "The fact that we Catholics honour Mary in heaven is part of the reason that some Evangelicals say we worship a pagan goddess...This is unfortunate because we don't know of any serious Catholic who actually knows anything about pagan religions or their goddesses. When Catholics think of Mary in heaven we think of the mother of Jesus, who is a 24/7 prayer warrior for faithful Christians. Her only goal is to point people toward her Son, our Lord and Saviour Jesus." |
Do Roman Catholics & Eastern Orthodox Worship Mary? | |
---|---|
Yes! | No! |
"Orthodox Christians do not worship the Theotokos and the saints; rather they venerate them. Anyone who claims that the Orthodox worship saints is guilty of bearing false witness against his neighbor since we clearly do not believe this." Coniaris |
Incorrect Understanding | Correct Understanding |
---|---|