Q. What do you do all day in a monastery?

A. We fall, and we get back up. We fall, and we get back up. We fall, and we ...

Eastern Monasticism Proverb
Monk


Preview

READ THIS Christian History Issue 64: Anthony & the Desert Fathers: Extreme Faith Spiritual Pragmatists

  1. Preview
  2. Two Roads
  3. Human Impulse
  4. Glossary
  5. Anchorites
    1. Spiritual Athletes
    2. Approaches to the Body
    3. Stylites
  6. Coenobites
    1. Pachomius
    2. Cistercians and Bernard of Clairvaux
    3. Benedictines
    4. Francis of Assissi and the Franciscans
    5. Dominic and the Dominicans
    6. The Jesuits
  7. Monasteries
    1. Universities
    2. Hospitals
  8. Review
  9. Sources


Revivals Are Not Just an Evangelical Thing [1 ]

Monasticism is a long series of revivals:
  1. With the end of persecutions, the Church grew worldly and weak. The Spiritual Athletes, the Anchorite monks, rose up against this worldliness and weakness.
  2. While their solitary existence kept them the Anchorites free from worldliness, it also kept these Spiritual Athletes from living out the Gospel within normal human relations. Recognizing this deficiency, a former soldier named Pachomius, founded a community where monks could support one another in their quest for a greater experience of God and to live out the Gospel's demands relating to social life. Pachomius also created a convent for women. These became the first Coenobitic monks, Coenobitic being a combination of two Greek words: koinos (common) and bios (life), the "life lived in common."
  3. Inspired by Pachomius, Basil the Great founds monasteries in Cappadocia, the Eastern part of the Roman Empire. Basil's Rule is still the cornerstone of Eastern Orthodox Monasticism.
  4. The harshness of the early Western monastic communities kept their numbers small. The Rule of Saint Benedict (529 AD) was strict enough for monks to feel they were living crucified lives, yet moderate enough for men less than supermen to survive. Monasteries using the Benedictine Rule spread throughout Western Christendom.
  5. Needing property for expansion, Benedictine monasteries allied themselves with their regional political rulers. This led to Investiture, a quid pro quid arrangement where rulers granted property to monasteries in exchange for the right to reward their political supporters with influential and wealthy church offices. The Cluniac Revival rose up against the Investiture abuse and allied themselves with the Pope in putting an end to this avenue for a completely secular church leadership.
  6. The Cluniac Revival ended a little over 100 years later with the Cluniac monasteries the center of lax and luxorious living. The Cistercians arose to combat the Cluniac dissapation.
  7. The pattern repeated with the Cistercians, their monasteries themselves became wealthy, propertied, and politically connected as their predecessors. When the Benedictine Order's corruption was apparent to all (c 1200), the mendicant (begging) orders—the Dominicans and the Franciscans—appeared with a solution. The Dominicans and Franciscans lived itinerant lives, begging their bread as they traveled from town to town preaching the Gospel.
  8. The Dominicans also became the scholarly wing of the Church, preserving the past and re-issuing it into the present via their preservation of the Scriptures and the great classical works of antiquity.
  9. The Jesuit Order arises to battle Protestantism.

The Two Roads

Monastic Motivations [2 ]

Galli

Monasticism Replaces Martyrdom? [3 ]

The Argument Against The Argument For
"Then again, the pioneers of the movement all began their desert lives before the "'peace of the church,' before things went supposedly lax. Antony took up asceticism over four decades before the persecution of Christians ceased, and he visited a number of Christian hermits who had already been living apart from society for years.

There seems to have been, then, some other motive driving Christians to abandon family and property and pray their days away."

While it is true that martyrs were still being made when the anchorites appeared, the waning of persecution created a vacuum filled by monasticism.

All through history there has always been a form of Heroic Christianity: martyrs, monks, reformers, and now missionaries.



Two Roads to God (Shelley, p. 126) [4 ]

"Monasticism, said Luther and the other Reformers, encourages the idea of two roads to God, a higher and a lower. But the gospel knows only one way to salvation."

I would argue that we're not necessarily talking about salvation here. I don't think anyone can deny that most Christians believe there are Christians who take their Christianity seriously and Christians who sort of coast along.

Those Who Aspire to Do More (Shelley, p. 126) [5 ]

"Shortly after the days of the apostles the idea of a lower and a higher morality appeared. We find it in a document, written about 140, called The Shepherd of Hermas. The New Testament, The Shepherd says, teaches precepts of faith, hope, and love binding upon all. But it also offers advice for those who aspire to do more than what is required of the ordinary Christian."

The World IN the Church (Shelley, p. 127) [6 ]

"Whatever Constantine's motives for adopting the Christian faith, the result was a decline in Christian commitment. The stalwart believers whom Diolcetian killed were replaced by a mixed multitude of half-converted pagans. Once Christians had laid down their lives for the truth; now they slaughtered each other to secure the prizes of the church. Gregory of Nazianzus complained, 'The chief seat is gained by evil doing, not by virtue, and the sees [ecclesiastical offices] belong, not to the more worthy, but to the more powerful.

The hermit often fled, then, not so much from the world as from the world in the church."


Not Just Spiritual, Physical and Political As Well [7 ]

"The monks, staunch and often audacious Christians, could be compliant or dangerous, depending upon the ebb and flow of any given controversy. The emperor Theodosius tried in 390 to limit their influence by bringing them under greater imperial control, and the great Byzantine emperor Justinian tried to do the same in 519. Both were only partially successful, because these monks, as the new martyrs, could never be entirely controlled. They insisted that righteousness, as they understood it, prevail." Calvert

Jerome (Crow and Galli) [8 ]



[9 ]



[10 ]



Monasticism: A Human Impulse

Type Non-Christian Monasticism Christian Monasticism
Hermits Before 600 BC - Hindu monks living in ashrams; no Rule EAST 300 AD – First desert monks living alone or in small groups with no Rule; WEST 400 AD – Celtic monks in Gaul
Monasteries From 600 BC – Jainists, a strict subset of Hinduism led by Mahavira, form communities of monks and nuns; 200 BC – Essenes form a monastic Jewish communityPachomius forms first monastic communities with a Rule; Benedict follows
Wanderers From 600 BC – Sangha, Buddist monks, wander, teach, preach, and beg Franciscan friars wander, teach, preach, and beg; later followed by the Dominicans


Non-Christian Monasticism: The Sadhus of Indian [11 ]
Non-Christian Monasticism: And Who Can Forget Our Favorite Buddist Monk ...

[12 ]
Kwai Chang Caine
Adrian MonkTrue, Some Christian Monks Were Certifiable Insane

St John of the Ladder is an Eastern Orthodox devotional classic, but everyone blanches at Chapter 5. Chapter 5 describes the separate building where monks voluntarily went for pentinence. Undoubtedly, some of these monks were severely mentally ill in an age where scrupulosity (a religious neurosis where one becomes obsessed with personal sinfulness), severe depression, and even paranoia were sometimes indistinguisable from excessive religious zeal.

James E. Goehring writes, "One hears of monks who walked on hot coals or scorpions or asps with their bare feet, of others whose unshaven hair alone served as their clothes, and still others who grazed with the antelope for food. Some monks wore chains and let their hair grow long, much to the dismay of others. Women shaved their heads and passed as male ascetics, their ruse discovered only in their death.

Onnophrius withdrew so far into the desert that Paphnutius had to walk over eight days and receive miraculous aid to reach him. Abba Bessarion avoided sleep for 14 days and nights by standing upright in the midst of thorn bushes, and Eulogius often fasted an entire week, eating only bread and salt. Pachomius bound ashes against his loins so that they ate away at him, and another monk's body became so irritated through his ascetic practices that he was infested with vermin. A solitary, or hermit, in lower Egypt avoided the temptation of a woman by shutting himself in his cell and dousing the flame of lust by thrusting his fingers one by one into the flame of his lamp."


Glossary

Laura, A Second Type of Monastic Community (Binns) [13 ]
"The monastery was really a settlement rather than a community. The rough and rocky terrain was not suited to the compact enclosed buildings and the cultivated fields of a "cenobitic," or communal, monastery. Instead, the monk in a "laura," as this style of monastery was called, lived through the week in his own cell, either alone or with one or two others. He prayed and occupied himself with simple handicrafts, such as making baskets or rope. On Saturdays he went to the buildings at the center of the laura for worship, a communal meal, and to exchange the completed baskets for raw material for the following week's work."

Chronology

[14 ]
Western Monasticism Highlights Eastern Monasticism Highlights
360 Martin of Tours takes up the monastic life
385 Jerome and companions found a monastery near Bethlehem;
404 Jerome translates the Pachomian Rule into Latin
c. 500 Benedict of Nursia withdraws to a cave to begin the monastic life
  • c. 251 Antony is born; Paul of Thebes begins living in the desert
  • c. 320 Pachomius founds the first monastic community, at Tabennesi
  • 358 Basil the Great founds his first monastery
  • 423 Simeon Stylites begins living on a pillar in Antioch, Syria
  • 478 Sabas founds the most important of the Palestinian laura


Anchorites

Why Do You Go Into the Desert? Because That's Where the Demons Are. [15 ]
Willie Sutton"The very word "pagan," meaning "rural" or "from the countryside," came to be used of the heathen customs, beliefs, and practices that still lingered in rural areas. As Christianity consolidated its position in the cities, many believed demons were forced to flee to the desert. So Antony and other monks went to the desert to do battle, much as Christ had gone into the desert and was "tempted by Satan, and was with the wild beasts" (Mark 1:13).
To the monks, the unseen spiritual powers they battled took the forms of Egyptian animal gods—Anubis the jackal god, Seckmet the lioness, or Sobek the crocodile. In this the monks were only following the lead of the apostle Paul, who himself had called the pagan gods demons (1 Cor. 10:21), and bishops like Cyprian of Carthage (c.220-258), who taught, "The demons hide within the garlanded statues and images."
And how did the monks fight these demon hordes? Not with their own power or wisdom, as had pagan philosopher-magicians, but with prayer, Scripture, the sign of the cross, and the name of Jesus."
Severance

Scripture As Their Guide [16 ]
"Scripture served as the ultimate guidebook for these men and women. They read it carefully and committed large portions of it to memory. Antony paid such close attention when he heard the Scriptures read that his memory served him in place of books. Pachomian monks memorized large portions of Scripture, especially the Psalms, and meditated upon them. In an ancient rock-cut tomb used by a monk as a cell, the owner painted the first line of each Psalm on the wall to aid him in his recitation of the entire text. The memorized text was then embodied in the ascetic's life." Goering

John Cassian (c.365-c.435) Stewart REWORK THIS INTO MY OWN WORDS [17 ]

STORAGE FOR COPY AND PASTES

Antony and the Desert Fathers: From the Editors - Models or Kooks? The questions that hover in the background of this issue are as pressing as ever. Mark Galli

In many stories, Antony is clearly a "new Adam," an example of restored humanity, one who is not subject to creation but master of it. In one incident, Antony scolds animals who had trampled his garden, and from then on, they no longer do so. In another story, a pack of hyenas threaten to attack him, but when Antony tells them to depart, they obey.

[18 ]



[19 ]



[20 ]



Spiritual Athletes

The World Had Changed, But the Word of God Had Not [21 ]

The days of persecution had gone away, but the Words of Scripture had not:

Choosing the Cross, a Life of Self-Denial
Deliberate Self-Mortification
Ascetic Examples: Christ and John the Baptist
Endorsement of Celibacy
Disposing of All Your Possessions
Donning the Shroud
Homeless - The Wandering Friars
Sleep Deprivation
Fasting


[22 ]



[23 ]



Approaches to the Body

The Body and Its Pleasures are Bad. The Body and Its Pleasures are Good,
but God is Better.
I understand this when I see it in Catholic monasticism, because Catholicism does not put as much stress as the Orthodox Church on the goodness of matter. I am surprised, however, when I see extreme ascetism in Orthodox monks. Our bodies are matter, and matter is good, but communion with God is better than enjoying the blessings of this material world.

Stylites

Simeon Stylites (Shelley, p. 128) [24 ]

"The reputations of some hermits attracted vast crowds of people from the cities. One, Simeon Stylites, was so troubled by crowds around the mouth of the cave where he lived, that he put up a pillar and made his home on the top of it for over thirty yers. Disciples sent up food to him in a basket, and from time to time, so we are told, he preached to the multitudes below, converting thousands to Christianity."

[25 ]



[26 ]



Coenobites

Monastic Rules (Shelley, p129) [27 ]

  1. c. 400 Augustine for monks at Tagaste and Hippo
  2. 415 John Cassian wrote two meditative books, which could be considered Rules
  3. Benedict of Nursia "provided the consititution for Western monasticism"


[28 ]



Pachomius

[29 ]



[30 ]



[31 ]



Cistercians and Bernard of Clairvaux

Bernard's Reform of the Benedictines Results in the Cistercian Order [32 ]



[33 ]



[34 ]



Benedictines

Benedict of Nursia (Shelley, ) [35 ]

  1. 529 - At Monte Cassino, Benedict wrote the Rule for what was to become the Benedictine Order.
  2. Benedict was an administrator who understood human strengths and weaknesses.
  3. Benedict's Rule balanced strict discipline with moderation in a way that made monastic life rewardingly difficult yet actually possible.
  4. Monks viewed monastaries as spiritual fortresses in a beseiged world.
  5. Monks were self-sufficent, making their own wine and beer, weaving their own Drunk Monkcloth, growing their own food, and doing their own carpentry and masonry work.
  6. Each monk vowed absolute obedience to the abbot's commands, but abbots were democratically elected and could decide weighty matters only after consulting the entire monastery..
  7. Monks were urged to remain inside the monastery walls.
  8. The daily schedule included seven services


[36 ]



[37 ]



[38 ]



Francis of Assissi and the Franciscans

[39 ]



[40 ]



[41 ]



Dominic and the Dominicans

[42 ]



[43 ]



[44 ]



The Jesuits

[45 ]



[46 ]



[47 ]



Monasteries

[48 ]



Universities

[49 ]



[50 ]



[51 ]



Hospitals

[52 ]



[53 ]



[54 ]



Sources